Flex Taxis Ltd has written to Lewis Cocking MP, Member of Parliament for Broxbourne, seeking his support over the effects of cross-border private-hire operations on locally licensed drivers and operators.
The letter asks the MP to work with Broxbourne Borough Council, the Department for Transport and Parliament to examine whether the current national licensing framework provides fair and sustainable competition.
This is not a request to prevent competition, restrict legitimate passenger choice or prohibit genuine cross-boundary journeys. It is a request to ensure that companies competing for passengers in Broxbourne operate under clear and comparable responsibilities.
Campaign Featured by TaxiPoint
The concerns raised by Flex Taxis have also been featured by TaxiPoint, a specialist news publication covering the UK taxi and private-hire industry.
In its article, “Broxbourne taxi operator calls for action over ‘unfair’ cross-border competition,” TaxiPoint reported on the pressure facing locally licensed operators and drivers, including rising operating costs, competition from national booking platforms and vehicles licensed outside Broxbourne.
The report also covered Flex Taxis’ requests for an independent assessment of the local trade, consultation with drivers and passengers, better evidence gathering and a national review of cross-border hiring arrangements.
Read the full TaxiPoint report:
Broxbourne taxi operator calls for action over ‘unfair’ cross-border competition
Why Flex Taxis Wrote to Lewis Cocking MP
Flex Taxis is a private-hire operator based in Cheshunt and licensed by Broxbourne Borough Council under operator licence number 156.
For several years, local taxi drivers, private-hire drivers and operators have reported declining customer numbers, pressure on fares and increasing difficulty covering their business costs.
Concerns have previously been raised with Broxbourne Borough Council. However, the Council has explained that its ability to address cross-border private-hire activity is limited because the underlying licensing framework is established through national legislation.
This creates a gap between local responsibility and national power. The Council licenses and regulates local operators, drivers and vehicles, but it cannot independently reform the national rules governing cross-border hiring.
Flex Taxis has therefore asked Lewis Cocking MP to help bring the relevant local and national bodies together.
What Is Cross-Border Private-Hire Working?
A private-hire journey must be booked through a licensed operator. The operator, driver and vehicle are generally required to be licensed by the same licensing authority.
However, the law permits journeys to cross local authority boundaries. This is necessary because passengers regularly travel between towns, boroughs, railway stations, hospitals and airports.
The concern is not an occasional journey beginning in one licensing area and ending in another.
The issue arises when drivers and operators licensed elsewhere repeatedly provide journeys that both begin and end within Broxbourne, particularly through national booking platforms that advertise to local residents and can dispatch nearby vehicles almost immediately.
Although such journeys may comply with the existing licensing framework, their practical effect is that businesses regulated directly by Broxbourne Borough Council compete with operators that have no operator’s licence issued by the Council.
Why Smaller Licensing Areas Are Particularly Exposed
Broxbourne is a relatively small borough with a naturally limited passenger market.
When a national platform brings a large network of out-of-area vehicles into that market, local drivers and operators must compete for a shrinking share of available journeys.
The effect may be more severe than in a large city because there are fewer passengers and commercially active taxi locations from which local businesses can earn a sustainable income.
National platforms can advertise widely, offer app-based booking and draw upon drivers licensed across much larger geographical areas. Independent operators cannot easily match that scale.
Flex Taxis believes this creates a structural disadvantage for businesses that invest in local licensing, serve local residents and remain directly accountable to Broxbourne Borough Council.
The Financial Pressure on Local Drivers and Operators
Locally licensed drivers and operators face substantial and increasing costs, including:
These costs must be recovered through fares. However, local operators may feel compelled to reduce their prices when passengers can instantly compare their quotations with those offered by national apps.
Flex Taxis reports that its revenue has fallen by approximately 75% during the period in which competition from national app-based platforms has intensified in Broxbourne.
This is the company’s own commercial experience. An independent assessment would be necessary to establish the full causes and measure the effects across the entire local trade. Nevertheless, such a substantial reduction represents a serious warning about the viability of a locally licensed operator.
Fair Competition Does Not Mean Protection From Competition
Flex Taxis is not asking the Government or Broxbourne Borough Council to protect local companies from ordinary competition.
Passengers should be able to compare providers, prices and service quality. Businesses should be encouraged to improve their services and use appropriate technology.
The issue is whether competition takes place under sufficiently comparable regulatory and commercial conditions.
Local operators pay for licences, maintain compliant vehicles, follow Council requirements and remain available to answer questions from local licensing officers.
A national platform may compete for the same passengers through an operator’s licence issued elsewhere. Broxbourne Council may therefore have limited direct authority over the operator accepting those bookings.
A competitive market should reward service quality, reliability, value and innovation. It should not place one group of businesses at a disadvantage because they accept direct accountability to the community in which they operate.
The Effect on Council-Approved Taxi Fares
Broxbourne Borough Council sets the maximum fare tariff for locally licensed Hackney carriages. Taxi meters must calculate fares according to that approved tariff.
The tariff is intended to reflect the cost of providing a safe, licensed and regulated service. However, app-based private-hire operators are not required to use the Council’s Hackney carriage tariff and can establish their own booking prices.
This can leave Hackney carriage drivers in a difficult position.
They cannot independently change their metered tariff whenever a national platform alters its prices or introduces a promotion. At the same time, passengers may expect local taxis to match prices displayed by an app.
Private-hire operators are not bound by the Hackney carriage tariff, but smaller local companies can face similar pressure. Charging less may retain some customers, but it can also make it difficult to cover insurance, vehicle, staffing and compliance costs.
If fares become commercially unsustainable, service standards and long-term availability may suffer.
Why Local Taxi Services Matter to Broxbourne
Locally licensed taxis and private-hire vehicles are an important part of Broxbourne’s transport network.
They provide journeys for:
Local companies also provide telephone booking, knowledge of neighbourhoods and direct accountability when passengers require help or wish to raise a concern.
If established operators close and experienced drivers leave the trade, residents may have fewer meaningful transport choices. The borough could become increasingly dependent on a small number of national platforms whose availability and pricing are determined remotely.
The Threat to Local Self-Employment
Taxi and private-hire driving provides an important form of self-employment.
Drivers invest in vehicles, insurance, maintenance, licensing, training and equipment. Like electricians, plumbers, locksmiths, carpenters and other independent tradespeople, they depend on fair access to local customers.
Weakening the Hackney carriage trade therefore also weakens an established part of Britain’s self-employment sector.
Technology should support innovation and consumer choice, but it should not make traditional local self-employment commercially impossible.
If drivers conclude that renewing their licences is no longer worthwhile, they may leave the trade. Wheelchair-accessible vehicles and other specialist services may also be lost if their operating costs cannot be recovered.
Why Broxbourne Council Still Has an Important Role
Although national legislation limits what the Council can do independently, Flex Taxis believes there are constructive actions it could take now.
Broxbourne Borough Council could:
Evidence gathering would not, by itself, change national law. However, it would give Broxbourne a stronger basis for requesting reform and help distinguish documented local effects from general perceptions.
What Flex Taxis Has Asked Lewis Cocking MP to Do
Flex Taxis has asked Lewis Cocking MP to:
These requests recognise that responsibility is shared. Broxbourne Council can collect evidence and examine local measures, while the Government and Parliament can consider changes to national legislation.
What Needs to Change Nationally?
The current framework must respond to the growth of national app-based platforms while preserving legitimate cross-boundary travel.
Possible reforms could include:
Any reform should be based on evidence and consultation. It should protect passengers while ensuring that local operators and self-employed drivers have a fair opportunity to remain viable.
A Sustainable Future Requires Balance
National apps have changed how passengers find and book transport. That innovation cannot simply be reversed, nor should useful technology be rejected.
However, innovation must operate alongside fair competition, passenger protection and meaningful local accountability.
Broxbourne should not have to choose between modern booking technology and a sustainable local taxi trade. Both can coexist if the regulatory framework ensures that companies serving the same local market accept comparable responsibilities.
Flex Taxis believes the Government, Parliament and Broxbourne Borough Council must work together before further local operators and experienced drivers are lost.
How Broxbourne Residents Can Help
Residents can contribute to a clearer understanding of the local transport market by sharing their experiences.
Useful information may include:
Constructive evidence from residents, drivers and businesses can help policymakers develop reforms that protect competition without reducing transport choice.
Conclusion
Broxbourne’s taxi and private-hire trade is not asking to be shielded from fair competition.
It is asking for a regulatory system in which companies competing for the same passengers operate under clear, comparable and accountable conditions.
Locally licensed drivers and operators provide more than individual journeys. They support self-employment, serve vulnerable passengers, maintain local knowledge and provide transport when other options are unavailable.
If these services are allowed to decline without proper assessment, the consequences will extend beyond individual businesses. Broxbourne could lose an important part of its local transport infrastructure.
Flex Taxis has asked Lewis Cocking MP to help ensure that this issue receives serious consideration from Broxbourne Borough Council, the Department for Transport and Parliament.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is cross-border private-hire working allowed?
Private-hire journeys frequently cross council boundaries because passengers travel between different towns, boroughs and airports. The law allows operators, drivers and vehicles licensed together by one authority to complete bookings beyond that authority’s boundaries.
Is Flex Taxis claiming that cross-border journeys are illegal?
No. The concern is not every cross-border journey. It is the cumulative effect of out-of-area operators repeatedly serving local journeys and competing for passengers without being directly licensed by the authority responsible for the pickup area.
Why can Broxbourne Borough Council not stop out-of-area operators?
Taxi and private-hire licensing operates under national legislation. A local council cannot independently rewrite the national rules or prevent lawful operations conducted through licences issued by other authorities.
What does fair competition mean in this context?
It means that businesses competing for the same local passengers should operate under clear and reasonably comparable licensing, safety and accountability requirements.
How could local residents be affected if taxi businesses close?
Residents could experience reduced availability, fewer telephone-booking options, loss of local knowledge and fewer suitable services for older or disabled passengers and people travelling when public transport is unavailable.
What action can Lewis Cocking MP take?
He can raise the matter with ministers, submit questions, seek meetings, encourage local evidence gathering and support a review of the national licensing framework.
Is this campaign directed against one company?
No. The underlying issue is the national regulatory framework governing cross-border private-hire operations and app-based platforms. Any reforms should apply fairly and consistently across the sector.
References
Department for Transport (2020) Statutory taxi and private hire vehicle standards. Available at: GOV.UK (Accessed: 13 September 2026).
Department for Transport (2022) Taxi and private hire vehicle licensing: best practice guidance. Available at: GOV.UK (Accessed: 13 September 2026).
Deregulation Act 2015. Available at: legislation.gov.uk (Accessed: 13 September 2026).
Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1976. Available at: legislation.gov.uk (Accessed: 13 September 2026).
Taxis and Private Hire Vehicles (Safeguarding and Road Safety) Act 2022. Available at: legislation.gov.uk (Accessed: 13 September 2026).
TaxiPoint (2026) ‘Broxbourne taxi operator calls for action over “unfair” cross-border competition’, 18 August. Available at: TaxiPoint (Accessed: 13 September 2026).
Disclaimer
This article presents the policy concerns and commercial experience of Flex Taxis Ltd. It does not allege that every cross-border private-hire journey is unlawful or that any operator has breached the law. The reported revenue reduction relates to Flex Taxis Ltd’s own business experience and should not be interpreted as an independent market-wide assessment. Licensing circumstances vary, and readers should obtain professional legal advice where necessary.
Posted: October 4, 2026